Learning to Give, Philanthropy education resources that teach giving and civic engagement

generationOn

Find Lesson Plans Browse Resources
Factions
Lesson 2:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Purpose:

Students will identify factions in society and recognize the problems/dangers/benefits of factional activities and/or fighting.

Duration:

Two to Three Forty-Five to Sixty-Minute Class Periods

Objectives:

The learner will:

  • define "faction."
  • explain the cause of "factions."
  • identify an example of "factions" in current world events.
  • cite problems/dangers created by "factional fighting."
  • predict at least one benefit of "factional" activities.

Materials:

  • The Butter Battle Book, by Dr. Suess
  • "One Tin Soldier" (recording and printed lyrics)
  • Unruled 5 x 9" cards
  • Teacher copy of Index Cards (Attachment One)
  • Teacher copy of Game: Dividing Into Groups (Attachment Two)
  • Teacher copy of Simulation Game (Attachment Three)
  • Student copies of Assessment (Attachment Four--Spanish version, Attachment Five)
  • Lined paper/drawing paper
  • Pencils, crayons, markers, etc. (writing/drawing tools)
  • Badges (see Attachment Three for directions)
Handout 1
Index Cards
Handout 2
Game: Dividing Into Groups
Handout 3
Simulation Game
Handout 4
Assessment
Handout 5
Evaluación

Instructional Procedure(s):

Anticipatory Set:
Divide the class into six cooperative groups of four-six students. Give each group an index card with three groups of people listed on it. See Index Cards (Attachment One). Each cooperative group must decide if the groups of people on their cards are communities, then explain why or why not.

 

Day One:

  • Read The Butter Battle Book aloud to the class, and then facilitate a discussion on the following questions:
    • What happened to the community in this book?
    • Why did this happen?
    • What was the difference of opinion about?
    • What was the result?

  • Use the results of this discussion to lead to the introduction of the term faction (a group with a common interest that is often quarrelsome or self-seeking). This definition should be written on a card and posted, along with the definition of community (from previous lesson).

  • Using Game: Dividing Into Groups (see Attachment Two), play a game to divide the class into factions.

Day Two:

Teacher Note: Part of this lesson is to be taught in one segment (early in the day), and will need to be completed and assessed at the end of the day.

  • Give each student a copy of the lyrics to a story that has been made into a song, "One Tin Soldier."
  • Tell the students to read along as the song is played. After hearing the song (once or twice, depending on the ability of the class), ask comprehension questions, such as:
    • What happened to the community in this song?
    • Why did this happen?
    • What are these groups called? (factions)
    • What was the result?
    • Does this happen in "real life?"
    • What are some examples? (race relations in the United States, religious differences in Northern Ireland, ethnic differences in Yugoslavia, tribal differences in Rwanda, older people/younger people, etc.)

Teacher Note: Students may be unfamiliar with some of these situations. If necessary, take time at this point to study some current or historical events.

    • Can any good things come from the activity of factions? What?

  • Have students take part in Simulation Game (see Attachment Three).

Assessment:

Give each student a copy of Assessment (see Attachment Four), a questionnaire that asks them to identify their feelings during the simulation. The questionnaire will also ask students to predict possible outcomes (if the simulation continued) and discuss some potential dangers, problems, or benefits of factional activities.

School/Home Connection:

Students (with adult assistance) can search for articles in periodicals (newspapers, magazines, etc.) that report examples of factional activities. These may be brought to school and posted on a bulletin board and/or read aloud or summarized by the students.

Cross-Curriculum Extensions:

Students can do additional research on an example of factional activities in historic or current events. These could be published as written or oral reports and/or pictures.

Bibliographical References:

  • Dr. Seuss, Theodore Seuss Geisel. The Butter Battle Book. Econo-Clad Books, 1999. ISBN: 0881034215.
  • "One Tin Soldier" available on Super Hits of the 70s: Have a Nice Day, Vol. 7. Catalog Number: 70927. UPC: 81227092726. Format: CD (Cassette available). Release date: April 4, 1990, Rhino Records.

Lesson Developed By:

Sally Engleman Cioe
Reeths-Puffer Schools
McMillan Elementary School
Muskegon, MI 49445

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Index Cards

Using six 5 x 9 (unruled) index cards, write the names of three groups on each card. Three cards will be groups that are examples of communities and three groups will be examples that are not communities. (These cards are to be used with this lesson's Anticipatory Set under Instructional Procedures.)

Groups that are communities:

Card One - Boy Scouts, Girls Scouts, 4-H Club

Card Two - Mickey Mouse Club, Sesame Street, Mister Rogers Neighborhood

Card Three - New York Yankees, Detroit Red Wings, Chicago Bulls

Groups that are not communities:

Card Four - baseball team, golfer, tennis player

Card Five - fans at a football game, shoppers in a store, patients waiting at a Doctor's office

Card Six - passengers on a bus, people at Pizza Hut, visitors at Disney World

Handout 2Print Handout 2

Game: Dividing Into Groups

  1. Designate two (or possibly three) separate locations within the classroom. An easy way to do this is to designate the north wall, the south wall, and the center of the room.

  2. Announce choices by which the students can classify themselves, for example, "Everyone who prefers chocolate ice cream, go stand by the North wall; everyone who prefers vanilla, go stand by the South wall." (Children should be encouraged to make a "forced choice" of one or the other.) Children who have special circumstances may remain in the center, for example: "Anyone with allergies to ice cream…"

  3. Announce other categories and tell children they must move each time to the location that signifies their choice. These categories may be created by the teacher, according to the population of the class.
    Examples of categories:
    Boys - Girls
    Only children - Have brothers and/or sisters
    Like cats best - Like dogs best
    Tall - Short
    Favorite food is pizza - Favorite food is something else
    Like country music - Do not like country music
    Wear glasses - Do not wear glasses
    (These are just examples. The possibilities are endless. Adjust categories to the makeup of your class.)


  4. Tell children to return to their own seats at the end of this activity.

  5. Briefly close/process this activity with this statement to elicit a student response. "Today we have divided up into many groups of people according to what we believe, or how we look, what we prefer, or who we are. Did you notice that sometimes certain people were in your group and other times there were different people in your group? Groups changed, depending on the question that was asked. These small groups that were formed could be called ______________?" (factions)

Handout 3Print Handout 3

Simulation Game

Note: Once begun, this game will be continued throughout the day, at the discretion of the teacher. At a given point, the students must change roles and then finish the simulation as the "other" faction.

Preparation: Make two sets of badges from construction paper that obviously contrast. Make one set of circles in one color (with "smiley" faces) and another set in a different color (with "frowning" faces.) Laminate these, if you wish. Have enough of one kind of badge for approximately half of the class and enough of the other for the remainder of the class.

Conceal the badges in an opaque container. Mix by shaking. Allow each student to draw one badge (without looking) and wear the badge on the right shoulder. Masking tape will work especially well, if the circles are laminated.

As soon as all students are wearing their badges, begin immediately to give preferential treatment to one set of students. Examples may include giving a candy treat to everyone with a "smiley" face, allowing them to line up first, giving them extra recess. The group with the "frowning" faces should be plainly discriminated against, such as, no drinks for those with frowning faces, no candy, last in line, etc. This should continue for a portion of the day, at the teacher's discretion.

When the teacher decides that the class is ready to change roles, each student with a "smiley" badge must trade with a student who has a "frowning" badge. (You may want to have some extras on hand, in case they become too worn out or lost.)

Resume preferential treatment of the students with "smiley" faces, as well as discrimination against those with the "frowning" faces. Important Note: All students must have reversed roles.

Continue in this manner throughout the day, while teaching other lessons and doing other activities. As you near the end of the day, allow enough time for the students to complete the processing questionnaire/assessment (see Attachment Four).

Handout 4Print Handout 4

Assessment

Each student must complete the questionnaire in an intrapersonal (self-smart) manner. He or she may not confer with others while working on this portion of the lesson.

  1. When I was wearing a "smiley" badge, I felt:


    because:




  2. When I was wearing a "frowning" badge, I felt:



    because:




  3. A "faction" is (definition)



    If the game had continued longer, one bad result of factional fighting might have been



    If the game had continued longer, one good result of factional activity might have been

Handout 5Print Handout 5

Evaluación

 

Cada estudiante debe de completar el cuestionario de una manera personal. El o ella no puede consultar con otros mientras trabaja en esta porción de la lección.  
1.    Cuando yo llevaba una “insignia sonriente”, me sentí:


porque:



2.    Cuando yo llevaba una “insignia con el ceño fruncido”, me sentí:



porque:



3.    Una "facción" es (definición)



Si el juego hubiese continuado, un mal resultado de la pelea de facción hubiese sido



Si el juego hubiese continuado, un buen resultado de la pelea de facción hubiese sido
 

Philanthropy Framework:

Comments

Donna, Teacher – Muskegon, MI10/25/2007 9:32:04 PM

(The positive aspect of using this lesson was) although we may have differences, we still can all belong to a community.

Janet, Teacher – Saginaw, MI10/25/2007 9:33:06 PM

(The positive aspect of using this lesson was) exposing the students to different people in our community. The students really enjoyed this lesson. I could have easily extended it for a week.
Also integration of Language Arts with Dr. Seuss' book The Butter Battle Book (great book). This book emphasized how "nonsense" can affect how we react to another and/or cause factions.

Mary, Teacher – Ionia, MI10/26/2007 8:53:13 AM

(The positive aspect of using this lesson was) the simulation. Very eye-opening for students. This was the best lesson.

Nicole, Teacher – Michigan Center, MI10/26/2007 9:09:21 AM

(The positive aspect of using this lesson was) the students were encouraged to see that it's OK to disagree about something, as long as, we handle ourselves appropriately. In the Butter Battle Book, kids saw how ridiculous it was for the two sides to argue over such a silly issue.

Janet, Teacher – Palm Desert, CA12/11/2010 11:27:45 PM

Thank you so much for providing such a wonderful site.
You have great lesson plans. I appreciate that they have such a positive message. God Bless Us Everyone!

Submit a Comment

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.