9th-12th Grade
Subjects:
Language Arts and Social Studies
Key Words/Concepts click to view
| ELA: | Group Discussions; Universal Themes; Vocabulary |
| PHIL: | Civil Society; Kindness; LEAGUE Event Lesson: King Day; Tolerance |
| SOC: | Democratic Values; Justice |
Purpose:
Learners will define justice, kindness, peace and tolerance. They will recognize these as attributes of a civil society. They will look for examples of their presence or absence in the news media and will brainstorm how they can promote them in their school, community and the world.
Duration:
One Fifty-Five Minute Class Period
Objectives:
The learner will:
- recognize issues of justice and the lack of justice in the press.
- identify examples of kindness and the lack of kindness in the press.
- find examples of conflict resolution by peaceful and violent means in the press.
- identify examples of tolerance and respect, and intolerance in the press.
Instructional Procedure(s):
Anticipatory Set:
Have the words justice, kindness, peace and tolerance posted on four pieces of large chart paper on the walls of the classroom when the students enter. Give each student Attachment One: The Vocabulary of a Civil Society with the definitions of these words. Discuss the definitions and have students come to consensus about a class definition in their own words. Ask for a student volunteer to write the class definition under each posted word on the chart.
- Divide the class into four groups, cut the Attachment Two: Role-Play Suggestions apart on the lines indicated and give one word/role-play to each group. Ask them to create a 30-second role-play using the idea on the piece of paper, or one of their own, to illustrate the lack or absence of the concept indicated.
- After the role-plays discuss with the students antonyms for the vocabulary words. (some are indicated on the role-play attachment) Help the students understand that justice, kindness, peace and tolerance are necessary attributes in a civil society.
- Organize the class into eight groups of three or four learners. Assign each group a topic: justice, kindness, peace, tolerance, injustice, meanness, violence and intolerance.
- Give each group enough newspapers so each student can be responsible for a different section of the paper. Students scan their respective section; cut out articles that reflect or illustrate their topic; and prepare to explain to the group how it illustrates the topic. As the students work, the teacher divides the vocabulary charts down the middle into two columns with a vertical line. One column should be labeled “YES” and the other column labeled “NO.”
Teacher Note: To do this lesson electronically you could access different newspapers through an Internet search engine such as google.com
- After the groups agree that the chosen articles represent the presence or absence of their assigned attribute, the students attach the articles to the appropriate vocabulary word wall-chart in the column indicating if the article represents an example of the presence of the attribute (justice/injustice, peace/violence, tolerance/intolerance or kindness/meanness) or not. (Some articles might be appropriate for more than one vocabulary word chart.) Students in each group should then sign their names to the chart to which they contributed.
- Give students time to do a walk-about in the room to scan each other’s articles.
- Brainstorm with the students’ ideas about how they can personally promote these four attributes of a civil society in their school, community and world. (These can be used at a later time to set a focus for a service project promoting justice and kindness.)
Assessment:
Teacher observation of learners will serve as the assessment.
LEAGUE Learning Link(s): (click to view)
Have an idea for a Learning Link?
If your Link is accepted for publication on the Web site you will be credited with your name, school, and city.
These "LEAGUE Learning Links” provide ten quick and easy 5-minute mini-lessons to help promote The LEAGUE’s vision and scheduled events in your classroom. You can choose from among these mini-lessons and use as many of them as you would like and in whatever order best meets your needs and the interest of your students. The purpose of these mini-lessons is to provide a deeper understanding of philanthropy (the giving of ones, time, talents, and treasures for the common good) and to promote those philanthropic acts that have been identified as supporting The LEAGUE events. These mini-lessons will also help ensure a deeper understanding of character traits, civic engagement, and promote student leadership. It is recommended that students be encouraged to play as much of a role as possible and appropriate in presenting these lessons to their classmates.
- Read: In the game of cricket there is a rule on the books (part 10 of Law 42) that reads: Any form of time wasting is unfair. Fortunately most rules are more specific than this one and less open to individual interpretation. But on the other hand there are rules that are written so specifically that only lawyers and courts can read and interpret them. Like laws, rules are meant to be interpreted in both letter and spirit. One rule that governs Major League Baseball pitchers is: A pitcher shall not deliver what is called a “shine” ball, “spit” ball, or “emery” ball. This is the letter of the rule! The spirit of the rule is: A pitcher shall not deface the ball in any manner.
Discuss: Someone once said, the simple reasons why we have rules is to help us stay safe, to learn, to play fair, and to get along. As we anticipate our King Day event, how might we enter into it in the spirit of the rules for this day as well as letter of rules for this day? How can we truly involve ourselves in what this day is intended to represent beyond the specifics of what we intend to do?
- Read: Early studies of the human brain concluded that the brain is divided into two hemispheres, the right and the left. Scientists think that there are distinct differences between these two hemispheres. While more recent studies have concluded that things are a little more complex than were originally thought to be, each half does have responsibility for different functions. The right hemisphere is typically associated with our emotions, our social inclinations, and our intuition. It is more creative, subjective, musical, more “big picture” and less detail-oriented. Our left hemisphere is more apt to be logical, objective, rational, analytical, and task oriented. We live in a society where 2/3 of the population is left brain dominant. Our schools, workplaces, government and military are typically all left-brain inclined and reward left brain activity. But researchers have shown that to function at ones optimum best, one needs to blend the functions of the right and left hemispheres. One researcher summed it up this way “To be effective human beings, we need to be as well as do.”
Discuss: When encountering a problem situation, our natural tendency is to want to fix it; to do things to make the problem situation go away. Often we act before we really understand the problem. Why is it important during our King Day event to actually know what the situation is that we are trying to improve before we go to work on improving it? How can we be as well as do and still accomplish our event’s objectives? Friendship is an extremely important part of our quest for higher consciousness; of our being-ness. What role will developing and nurturing friendship play during our King Day event? What are some ways we can be a friend to others in addition to doing things with a friend?
- Read: The name César Chávez is known among immigrant farm workers in much the same way that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s name is known among African-Americans. In fact, he is hailed by many as one of the greatest American civil rights leaders alongside Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.. Growing up, Mr. Chávez experienced the pangs and pains racism. He did not like school as a youth. He remembered being punished with a ruler to his knuckles for speaking Spanish. Some schools were segregated, and he frequently encountered unkind remarks. He and his brother Richard attended thirty-seven schools over the course of their Kindergarten through eighth grade education. Unable to attend high school due to an accident involving his father that required him to work in the fields to support the family, Mr. Chávez didn’t complain. Eventually, he left the fields to enlist in the Navy. He served two years during WWII. Upon his return he found himself meeting and being influenced by Father Donald McDonnell. They talked about farm workers and strikes. Mr. Chávez read about St. Francis of Assisi, Gandhi and nonviolence protests. He decided that improvements in labor were needed. He went to work doing just that. Today, he is considered a hero of farm workers, due to his non-violent approach to helping keep wages higher and improve work safety rules for all farm workers.
Discuss: As we approach our King Day event, what other figures might stand next to Dr. King and Mr. Chávez in their effort to promote fairness and justice in a non-violent manner? What do you think might motivate people like Dr. King and Mr. Chávez to involve themselves in such peace projects? What do you think would motivate someone to enlist in the military in support of a country that had treated him/her unfairly? What are some ways our King Day event is a non-violent attempt to promote fairness, justice, and kindness?
- Read: There is a world-wide project underway celebrating diversity, encouraging tolerance and promoting compassionate communities. It is called The Thread Project: One World of Cloth. Seven amazing cloth panels have been woven from threads gathered from thousands of people of all faiths, cultures and ideologies from 70 countries covering seven continents. Just as the seven continents create one world, and the seven colors of the color spectrum create one light, these seven cloths create one world cloth. The threads for these seven panels represent the very fabric of everyday life. They come from everywhere and including clothing, fishing rods, shoes, blankets, guitars and hundreds of other sources. Some threads reflect tragic events such as those gathered on the Killing Fields of Cambodia, from 9/11 families and a Holocaust survivor. Other threads are spun with the joy of birth, marriage and celebration. Terry Helwig, Founder of the project says, “Some say the world is hanging on by a tread. I say- a thread is all we need.” The cloth panels, which took nearly five years to complete, are now being exhibited to remind people that we are ultimately a global family of one, united by a common thread
Discuss: In what ways do you see our world “hanging by a thread”? Our King Day event is intended to be recognition and a celebration of diversity, tolerance and compassion. In what ways can our King Day event be likened to The Thread Project? What “thread” runs through our event that we hope will serve as a reminder to people that we are ultimately a global family?
- Read: The game of bowling has been around forever it seems. One historian says that the game can be traced to the “most ancient of times”. Through all those years, however, the game of bowling has seen many changes. One of the more recent changes was the elimination of a pinsetter, or pin spotter. Originally this was a person (usually a teenage boy, also known as a pin boy) who would manually reset bowling pins in their correct position, clear fallen pins, and return bowling balls to the players. It was a low paying job that soon fell out of favor with most boys who could gain better employment wages elsewhere. It was Gottfried Schmidt who invented the mechanical pinsetter, which largely did away with pin setting as a manual profession. Today, many mechanical pinsetters are integrated with electronic scoring systems. While the entire process of the mechanical pinsetter is quite complicated, there is a very interesting button that connects with it located within reach of each bowler. This button is called the reset button. It is intended to be pushed in the event that things are not going right and need to be corrected. The button may also be pushed when the bowler would like a “do-over” although this usage is frowned upon by the management of most bowling allies in many instances.
Discuss: Wouldn’t it be nice if there was a reset button available to us when things in our lives are not going right and need to be corrected? If you were in charge of the reset button for our world what would be some of the things you would want to re-set? How can our involvement in our King Day event be like having a reset button available to us? Is there a greater potential for "do-overs” in our lives or a greater potential for “do different-lys”? In what ways might our King Day be a “do differently” day?
- Read: The St. Louis Post- Dispatch recently carried an article about 13 year old Josh Pillman from St. Charles, Missouri. This year Josh was serving as the junior co-chairman for “A Tasteful Affair”, a fundraiser for Food Outreach, which provides meals for low income people living with HIV, AIDS, and cancer. He has been traveling around the country talking to groups about HIV and AIDS since he was ten years old. In the summer he attends Camp Heartland, a program specifically designed for children affected by HIV and AIDS. Josh was born HIV positive as a result of his mother having received a tainted blood transfusion. When asked why he thought people sometimes discriminate against people with HIV-AIDS, he responded, “They don’t understand, and they discriminate against people because they are afraid."
Discuss: Do you agree or disagree with Josh’s response to the question asking why some people discriminate against people with HIV-AIDS? Why? Do you think that all discrimination is the result of fear? Why or why not? How might what we do for our King Day event help reduce discrimination in our homes, school, and/or community.
- Read: Do you know of anyone who reads using Braille? In the early 1800s, a three year old boy named Louis Braille was helping his father in his father’s workshop. Louis accidentally injured his eye, resulting in his becoming blind. But young Louis did not allow his blindness to keep him from doing what he wanted to do. He became a talented musician, playing both the cello and the organ. Receiving a scholarship at the age of 10, he attended school and was introduced to a system of embossed paper with typical roman type to help blind students read by moving their fingers across the printed word. It was a very time consuming process. Meanwhile, a French army captain, Charles Barbier, had invented a system called “night writing” to enable messages to be written and read on battle fields at night. It used variations on a basic pattern of 12 raised dots on paper that translate into words. This allowed people to read in the dark by moving their fingers across the dots. Having been introduced to this process, Louis Braille later reduced the 12-dot code to six dots and worked out a basic alphabet and a series of contractions to help speed up the rate of reading. Today, using the Braille method, a blind person is able to read almost as quickly and easily as someone who isn’t blind.
Discuss: What can we learn from Louis Braille’s not letting his handicap keep him from being and doing what he wanted to be and do? It could be said that because of the combined efforts of three different individuals, the Braille reading process is better able to provide for the needs of the blind. What could be some of the benefits for our King Day event if we combined our efforts and all worked together?
- Read: The television series, Cold Case, is a drama about Lilly Rush a female detective on the Philadelphia homicide squad, who finds her passion when she is assigned to cold cases. These are the unsolved cases where crimes were committed many years ago and have been all but forgotten. Using all of the new science and technology to find new clues, she solves these old cases and brings justice and resolution for the victims of those crimes.
Discuss: Why do you think this series has become so popular? How does the justice that Lilly Rush seeks for her clients speak to the ideal of fairness, equality, and a sense of rightness? How might these ideals be reflected in our King Day event? How is involving ourselves in our King Day event a way to help solve some of the unresolved situations in our world that might have occurred years and years ago?
- Read: In 1921, “Shoeless” Joe Jackson was banned from baseball due to his alleged involvement in the Black Sox scandal of 1919. He, along with some of his Chicago White Sox teammates, supposedly participated in a conspiracy to fix the World Series. Though never convicted, he was banned and would not ever play the game of baseball at a professional level again.
According to Jackson, he got his nickname during a game with the Brandon Mill team. Jackson suffered from a blister on his foot from a new pair of baseball shoes. They hurt so much that he had to take his shoes off before going up to bat. From then on he was known as “Shoeless Joe”.
In January, 2008, IUPUI (Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis) basketball coach, Ron Hunter went “shoeless” during a basketball game with the University of Oklahoma. While he too was allegedly suffering from a sore foot, his “shoeless-ness” was intended for a greater purpose. He was hoping to raise awareness of the fact that many children throughout the world do not have shoes to wear. His efforts were rewarded. His goal was to get 40,000 pairs of shoes donated to be sent to Africa in honor of the 40th anniversary of the death of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Working with Samaritan Feet, Soles4souls, and other profit and non-profit businesses and organizations, prior to the start of the IUPUI, University of Oklahoma game, 100,000 pairs of shoes had already been donated. One thing is for sure, there will be fewer “shoeless” children in Africa!
Discuss: Sometimes we can do silly things and have great results. What do you think might motivate someone like Ron Hunter, an esteemed college basketball coach, to become a “Shoeless Ron”? Would you say that his silliness had a motivational impact? What could we do to draw attention to our King Day event that might have a motivational impact and increase participation?
www.topix.com/forum/sports/T33SERT389VVF07T4
http://www.soles4souls.org/
http://www.samaritansfeet.org/
- Read: Most of the requirements for someone to become a naturalized U.S. citizen, have to do with residency requirements. One, however, does deal with character. To be considered for citizenship in the United States, one must also be of "good moral character." This is a legal term, and is not necessarily the same as being a "good person," as opposed to being a "bad person." A person whom you might think of as a "good person," Immigration might think is a person who does not have "good moral character" and therefore should not be granted U.S. citizenship. The following are just some of the situations where Immigration would say a person does not have "good moral character" and deny them citizenship:
-
a man has lived in the United States at some point during the ages of 18 and 25, but did not register for "Selective Service".
-
the person has a drinking problem (especially if arrested for driving while drunk).
-
the person has ever had children with a person to whom he was not married.
-
the person has children but does not live with them, and is not paying child support for the children.
-
the person got public benefits such as food stamps, but did not tell his benefits caseworker right away when he began working again or when he took a brief trip outside of the U.S.
-
the person has ever lied to Immigration, for example, on earlier applications for permanent residency.
Discuss: How difficult do you think it might be for some U.S .Citizen to “pass” this ‘good moral character’ test? Do you think these requirements are too strict for those making application for U.S. Citizenship? Why or why not? How is our King Day helping to promote good moral character in our school, home, community, and/or nation?
www.ptla.org/immigrants/english/citizenship.htm
Extension:
Encourage students to be observant in the next few days for positive and negative examples of the attributes. Have them write up a brief description of what they observed, not using any person’s name, and add them to the appropriate chart.
Post Service Reflection: (click to view)
Reflection plays a very important role in promoting student learning. The following suggested activities are ways to help students reflect on their learning after they have participated in a service event. Choose one or more of the activities most appropriate to the service event and your students.
ACTIVITY ONE:
Have each student write a one or two sentence response to at least three of the following prompts:
- During this LEAGUE Event, I learned how to…
- During this LEAGUE Event, changed my mind about…
- During this LEAGUE Event, I was feeling…
- During this LEAGUE Event I thought ….
- During this LEAGUE Event I was hoping that…
- During this LEAGUE Event I became convinced of…
Encourage the students to share their responses to the prompts they selected and have them look for similarities and differences in the responses of others. Conclude this activity by having students come up with three or four single words that reflect the majority of responses given to each prompt. Write these words on the display board. Have the students share why it might be difficult to ‘put into words’ what they experienced during this LEAGUE Event.
ACTIVITY TWO:
Provide the students with the following questionnaire. Using a Likert scale rating 0-5 with 0 meaning “not at all” to 5 meaning “very much so”, have them circle their responses. Instruct the students not to place there name on the questionnaire.
| |
Not at All > Very Much So
|
| 1. I was fully prepared to participate in this LEAGUE Event. |
0 1 2 3 4 5
|
| 2. What I expected would happen during this LEAGUE Event happened. |
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
| 3. The feelings I had about participating in this LEAGUE Event, remained the same from start to finish. |
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
| 4. I think the LEAGUE Event had positive impacts. |
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
5. I felt that everyone worked together to make this LEAGUE Event the success that it was.
|
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
| 6. I have given some consideration to how I might be able to be involved in other service events in our school/community. |
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
| 7. Should participation in this LEAGUE Event be required of all 9th graders next year? |
0 1 2 3 4 5 |
When each student has completed their questionnaire, have them exchange their questionnaires with another student. Do this exchange two additional times. Now have the students call out the response numbers to each of the questions as you record hash marks (IIII) for each question on a display area for all to see. Engage the students in a discussion of what the class responses to these questions tell them about this LEAGUE Event?
ACTIVITY THREE:
Place the following slogans on the display board:
- Diamonds are forever (DeBeers)
- Just do it (Nike)
- The pause that refreshes (Coca-Cola)
- We try harder (Avis)
- Good to the last drop (Maxwell House)
- Breakfast of champions (Wheaties)
- Does she ... or doesn't she? (Clairol)
- When it rains it pours (Morton Salt)
- Where's the beef? (Wendy's)
Tell the students that these slogans have been identified as the Top Ten Slogans of the Century. Have each student decide which of these slogans (or one that they come up with on their own/or one that is more contemporary) he/she thinks might best represent their personal over all feeling about their involvement in this LEAGUE Event. Encourage the students to share their selected slogan and their reason for selecting it. Discuss how slogans could be used to promote future LEAGUE Events.
ACTIVITY FOUR:
Pair the students and provide them with a “Person in the Street” Interview form (see below). Indicate that each student will take turns interviewing and being interviewed using this form as a guide. Each interviewer is responsible for recording the information he/she obtains from their interviewee during the interview. The interviewer should “read back” to the interviewee what it is that he/she recorded/heard them say in response to the interview questions. Once the interviewee agrees that what he/she said was accurately recorded, the interviewer is responsible to write a one-page newspaper article about the interviewee and his/her experiences during the Event.
“Person in the Streets” Interview:
- What is you name?
- What was your role in this LEAGUE Event? What did you do during this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel the night before this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel during this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel after this LEAGUE Event?
- Do you think you did your best during this LEAGUE Event?
- If you had it to do over again, are there some things you would do differently? If so, what things would you change?
- Do you feel that this was a worthwhile LEAGUE Event? Why or Why Not?
- Any recommendations/suggestions for next year’s LEAGUE Event?
Pair the students and provide them with a “Man in the Street” Interview form (see below). Indicate that each student will take turns interviewing and being interviewed using this form as a guide. Each interviewer is responsible for recording the information he/she obtains from their interviewee during the interview. The interviewer should “read back” to the interviewee what it is that he/she recorded/heard them say in response to the interview questions. Once the interviewee agrees that what he/she said was accurately recorded, the interviewer is responsible to write a one-page newspaper article about the interviewee and his/her experiences during the Event.
“Person in the Streets” Interview:
- What is you name?
- What was your role in this LEAGUE Event?
- What did you do during this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel the night before this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel during this LEAGUE Event?
- How did you feel after this LEAGUE Event?
- Do you think you did your best during this LEAGUE Event?
- If you had it to do over again, are there some things you would do differently? If so, what things would you change?
- Do you feel that this was a worthwhile LEAGUE Event? Why or Why Not?
- Any recommendations/suggestions for next year’s LEAGUE Event?
Bibliographical References:
- Webster’s New Universal Unabridged Dictionary. Random House, 1996.
- Learning to Give Web site at www.learningtogive.org, Resource Room, Vocabulary
Lesson Developed and Piloted by:
Jerry Morris, Ph.D.
Curriculum Consultant
Learning to Give
Barbara Dillbeck
Curriculum Director
Learning to Give
Handouts:
The Vocabulary of a Civil Society
The Vocabulary of a Civil Society
Justice - (n) 1. the principle of moral or ideal rightness; conformity to the law; the abstract principal by which right and wrong are defined. 2. the quality of being just, righteousness, equitableness, or moral rightness. 3. the moral principle determining just conduct. 4. conformity to this principle determining just conduct.
Peace - (n) 1. freedom of the mind from annoyance, distraction, anxiety, an obsession, etc.; tranquility, serenity; calm; 2. the absence of war; 3. the state of mutual harmony between people; 4. the normal freedom from civil commotion and violence of a community, public order and security.
Kindness – (n) 1. An act of goodwill; state or quality of being kind; 2. a kind act or behavior; 3. friendly feeling, liking.
Tolerance – (n) 1. a fair, objective, and permissive attitude toward those whose opinions, practices, race religion, nationality, etc., differ from one’s own; freedom from bigotry; 2. to recognize and respect the opinions and rights of others; 3. the act or capacity of enduring.
Webster’s New Universal Unabridged Dictionary. Random House, 1996.
www.learningtogive.org, Resource room, Vocabulary
Role Play Suggestions
Demonstrating the absence of the Civil Society attributes represented in vocabulary words.
Divide the class into four groups, cut these apart on the lines and give one word/role-play to each group. Ask them to create a 30 second role-play using the idea on the piece of paper, or one of their own, to illustrate the lack or absence of the concept indicated.
***************************************************************************************************
Justice - (injustice, bigotry, stereotype, discrimination, unfairness, inequity) A telephone conversation between a possible tenant seeking a rental. Callers use voices representing different ethnicities or socio-economic status and is told there are no rentals available until the caller “sounds” white and educated.
***************************************************************************************************
Peace - (war, violence, disorder, conflict) A person sitting next to another person who is taping his/her pencil. The first person saying he/she is sick and tired of a the tapping, taking the pencil, breaking it in half and throwing it on the floor.
***************************************************************************************************
Kindness – (meanness, thoughtlessness, viciousness, malevolence, harshness) A person talking to someone and making a negative comparison of him/her to a third person, and saying he/she is worthless compared to the third party and will never amount to anything.
***************************************************************************************************
Tolerance - (intolerance, impatience, disrespect) A line of people is waiting to pay in a store, the first person is obviously elderly and is moving slowly to get out their money and is having difficulty in hearing and understanding the checkout person. The person behind them is obviously impatient and begins to use body language that communicates their impatience as well as imitating the elderly person in a derogatory way in an attempt to amuse his/her companions.