Learning to Give, Curriculum Division of The LEAGUE

The LEAGUE

Questioning Our Definition—Acts of Courage
Lesson 3:
printEmail this Lesson
Lesson
Handouts
Academic Standards
Philanthropy Framework

Purpose:

Students will demonstrate the importance that public advocacy for the common good has in developing civic virtue and core democratic values by successfully writing a research- based persuasive essay.

Duration:

Three Fifty-Five Minute Class Periods

Objectives:

The learners will:

  • develop, in writing, the definition of heroes and public advocacy from Lesson One: What Is a Hero?
  • identify advocacy and philanthropy in context of societal norms in text and media.
  • define the aspects of advocacy by breaking it down to its components.
  • research and support an opinion with factual evidence.
  • compose a persuasive essay demonstrating the elements of grammar, usage, content in subject and philanthropy.

Materials:

Instructor Note: The instructor will collect quotes regarding unconventional ideas of courage. Texts and/or media, discussing controversial/unconventional heroes for these quotes, may be found in the Bibliographical References.

  • Journal which was begun in Lesson One and continued in Lesson Two

  • Computer Lab and/or library time to research.

  • Attachment One: Persuasive Essay Framework

  • Attachment Two: Writing In Progress

  • Attachment Three: Rubric for the Persuasive Essay
Handout 1
Writing Persuasive Essays
Handout 2
Writing In Progress
Handout 3
Rubric For Assessing the Persuasive Essay

Instructional Procedure(s):

Day One:

Anticipatory Set:
Put the following quote on the board or provide the students with the quotes you have gathered and have them select two for reflection writing.

    “ The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
    — George Bernard Shaw .

  • Have students reflect by agreeing or disagreeing in a journal writing, one paragraph in length. The paragraph must have a topic sentence and provide one supporting reason. Discuss their journal responses. What do they mean? Do you agree? Disagree? Have a student recorder place key responses on a board or sheet of paper for the class to see.

  • Discuss what part courage plays in being a hero. Is a hero always courageous? Discuss if the terms must go together. Discuss the ways courage could be physical or intellectual. Examples are: saving a person from a raging stream, standing up for an idea, cause or position. Review the examples of advocacy for the common good they developed in Lessons One and Two.

  • Give each student Attachment One and use direct instruction on the elements of a persuasive essay. Explain that their task will be to write a persuasive essay in which they will persuade the reader to become an advocate for the common good.

     
  • Students will pick their topic for writing the persuasive essay. Talk about different types of courage i.e., courage to stand up for what you believe in even if it is not socially acceptable, courage to be different, courage to not act. Potential examples: local, state or national heroes from media who use their fame for advocacy for the common good, athletes, civil rights activists, the rescuers of the nine trapped miners in Pennsylvania, the miners themselves, the passengers and crew that subdued the “Shoe Bomber” in December of 2001.
    Instructor Note: Use examples also of the students who founded SAAD, DARE program members, volunteers at shelters and community programs. Hospitals are also key advocates for the common good.

  • Instructions for the persuasive essay:
    The expected outcome will be to persuade readers that advocacy for the common good, as demonstrated by their research, is central to core democratic values. They are to persuade others to become involved in public advocacy. Encourage students, that as they look for their issue or topic, no issue or cause is too small. You may cite a local community issue such as convincing the local township or city to place a traffic light at a dangerous corner or railroad crossing. They can research how other groups, and perhaps student groups, convinced other localities to do the same.
    Writers are to cite resources used in proving their argument using the style sheet your school recommends.
    A bibliography is to be attached to the essay.
    Assessment will be based on Attachment Three: Rubric for persuasive Essay.

  • Discuss the Rubric and your expectations, including length of essay. It is suggested that a reasonable expectation would be four to five pages, with a minimum of three supportive facts fully documented.

  • Select a peer-edit partner. You may also use the writing pod of three to four students as peer editors.

  • Complete Attachment Two for Day One and leave with the instructor.
    Instructor Note: Record and return to the student the next day.

  • Direct students that they may bring to class any materials they may need for research.

  • Schedule computer time or media center time for students.

    Days Two and Day Three:

  • Research the topic for the persuasive essay. Submit Attachment Two at the end of the class session.

  • Choose texts and/or media telling stories of controversial and/or unconventional heroes using text, printed material or Internet research. See the Bibliography for suggestions.

  • Complete an outline based on Attachment One and present that outline to the peer editor or writing pod. Make additions, deletions or corrections before beginning their research.

  • Organize their research and begin the rough draft of their persuasive essay using Attachment One as the template. Allow ten minutes each day to peer edit.

  • Continue and finish the essay for submission on Day Four.

    Day Four:

  • Students share and discuss their persuasive essays.
    Reflection/transition to Lesson Four:
    Journal prompt: Convincing someone else to do the right thing makes me________.

Assessment:

Attachment Two, daily writing progress, class participation, teacher observation, Persuasive Essay Rubric (Attachment Three)

Extension:

  • Students write a letter to an advocacy organization in support of their efforts.

  • Have the students collect visual/audio representations of courage and present them to the class—what does courage look/sound like? Why did you choose what you chose?

  • Have students write brief improvisational scenes where they display alternative forms of courage.

Bibliographical References:

  • Levine, Ellen. Freedom’s Children. New York: An Avon Flare Book, 1993. ISBN: 0606058354
    Thirty African Americans who were teens in the 1950s and 1960s give oral histories of their involvement in the struggle for civil rights. All of the stories are true. ~ ALA Booklist Editor’s Choice ~ School Library Journal Best Book of the Year.

  • Lewis, Barbara A. Kids with Courage: True Stories about Young People Making a Difference. MN: Free Spirit Publishing, 1992. ISBN: 0915793393
    Biographies of young people who are making their communities a better place by the work that they do to help others and themselves.

  • Davenport, May. Courage: An Anthology of Short Stories, Articles and Poems. May Davenport Publishing, 1979. ISBN: 0960311831. An excellent resource!

  • Various Artists. America: A Tribute to Heroes. Interscope Records, 2001.
    CD commemorating September 11th. Artists as varied as Bruce Springsteen, Limp Bizkit, Stevie Wonder and Faith Hill.

  • Longman, Jere. Among the Heroes: United Flight 93 and the Passengers and Crew Who Fought Back. HarperCollins, First ed., July 30, 2002. ISBN: 0060099089

Lesson Developed and Piloted by:

Michelle Strang
Muskegon Public Schools
Muskegon High School
Muskegon, MI 49441

Handouts:

Handout 1Print Handout 1

Writing Persuasive Essays

They could do it because they believed they could.
Vergil
70 - 19 B.C. Roman

In persuasive writing, we try to convince others to agree with our facts, share our values, accept our argument and conclusions, and adopt our way of thinking. 

Elements toward building a good persuasive essay include

  • establishing facts  
    to support an argument
  • clarifying relevant values  
    for your audience (perspective)
  • prioritizing, editing, and/or sequencing
    the facts and values in importance to build the argument
  • forming and stating conclusions
  • “persuading” your audience that your conclusions
    are based upon the agreed-upon facts and shared values
  • having the confidence  
    to communicate your “persuasion” in writing

Here are some strategies to complete a persuasive writing assignment:

Write out the questions in your own words.

  • Think of the questions posed in the assignment
    while you are reading and researching. Determine
    • facts
    • the source of the facts for reliability and later reference
    • source of the facts for prejudice
    • values that color the facts or the issue
    • what you think of the author's argument
    • List out facts ; consider their importance:
      prioritize, edit, sequence, discard, etc.
      Ask yourself “What's missing?”
    • What are the “hot buttons” of the issue?
      List possible emotions/emotional reactions and recognize them for later use.  

Start writing a draft!
Start as close as possible to your reading/research. Do not concern yourself with grammar or spelling at this point. You will correct for grammar and spelling later.

  • Write your first paragraph
    • Introduce the topic
    • Inform the reader of your point of view!
    • Entice the reader to continue with the rest of the paper!
    • Focus on three main points to develop
  • Establish flow from paragraph to paragraph
  • Keep your voice active
  • Quote sources to establish authority
  • Stay focused on your point of view throughout the essay
  • Focus on logical arguments
  • Don't lapse into summary
    in the development--wait for the conclusion
  • Conclusion
    • Summarize, then conclude, your argument
    • Refer to the first paragraph/opening statement as well as the main points
      • Does the conclusion restate the main ideas?
      • Reflect the succession and importance of the arguments
      • Logically conclude their development
  • Edit/rewrite the first paragraph
    to better telegraph your development and conclusion.
  • Re-read your paper
    with a fresh mind and a sharp pencil

•  Ask yourself:  
Does this make sense?  Am I convinced?

    • Will this convince a reader? 
      Will they understand my values, and agree with my facts?
    • Edit, correct, and re-write as necessary
    • Check spelling and grammar!
    • Have a friend read it and respond to your argument.  
      Were they convinced?
    • Revise if necessary
    • Turn in the paper
    • Celebrate a job well done,
      with the confidence that you have done your best.

How to respond to criticism:  
Consider criticism as a test of developing your powers of persuasion. 
Try not to take it personally.

If your facts are criticized , double check them, and then cite your sources.

If your values are criticized , sometimes we need to agree, “to disagree."  Remember: your success in persuading others assumes that the other person is open to being persuaded!

The Study Guides and Strategies web site was created and is maintained by Joe Landberger,
academic web site developer at the University of St. Thomas (UST), St. Paul, Minnesota.  It is collaboratively maintained across institutional and national boundaries, and  last revised September 04, 2002 . 

Permission is granted to freely copy, adapt, print, transmit, and distribute
Study Guides in settings that benefit learners.

 

Handout 2Print Handout 2

Writing In Progress

Name ___________________________________

Edit Partner or Writing Pod Members

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

Topic for persuasive essay

I am going to use the following for my research. (Note: use proper bibliographic citing.)

 

 

 

I completed the following part(s) of my essay today.

 

 

 

My tasks for work at home and in class for tomorrow are:

 

 

 

My evaluation of my progress so far is:

 

 

 

My peer editor has made the following suggestion(s)

 

Handout 3Print Handout 3

Rubric For Assessing the Persuasive Essay

Four Points Introduces topic, informs, provides three examples as evidence, has excellent flow , establishes facts with documentation,   clarifies relevant values and issues,   prioritizes the argument for advocacy, demonstrates editing, stated conclusions , grammatical structure, style demonstrated at a minimum of 90% accuracy, elements of public advocacy clearly demonstrated in essay, a minimum of two research resources used, work properly cited, bibliography correct to style sheet. The essay persuades and is convincing in support of advocacy. Attachment Two submitted for each class session, works with peer editor consistently, evidence of peer editing observed by instructor, essay submitted on time, writer volunteered for presentation discussion. Timelines met
Three Points Introduces the topic and connects it to advocacy, give two facts and supportive detail, editing is evident, a minimum of two resources used, bibliography provided, style consistent with template. Grammar and structure within 75% accuracy. Attachment Two showing daily progress is submitted for two days, peer cooperation demonstrated, writer contributed to class presentation. Timelines met
Two Points A persuasive essay is submitted. The topic is stated but only one source is used, advocacy addressed, bibliography included but not aligned to style form. There was an attempt at editing. 60% accuracy in writing conventions and grammar. An attempt to complete Attachment Two is made. Peer editing is inconsistent. Essay submitted. Some timelines not met. Writer participates in discussion.
One Point An attempt at writing a persuasive essay is made. Research is not documented, bibliography not provided, elements of style and grammar are less than 50%. Peer editing is attempted. No evidence of Attachment Two is present, essay is submitted but timelines are not met. Student has minimal class participation
No Points No attempt is made and essay not submitted. There was no cooperation with the peer editor.

 

Philanthropy Framework:

Submit a Comment

Unit Contents:

Overview:Heroism In Literature Summary

Lessons:

1.
What Is a Hero? Heroism in Greek Mythology
2.
Heroism in English Myth
3.
Questioning Our Definition—Acts of Courage
4.
Heroism—Opportunities for Action

All rights reserved. Permission is granted to freely use this information for nonprofit (noncommercial), educational purposes only. Copyright must be acknowledged on all copies.

Copyright © LearningToGive.org